What Are Counterintuitive Effects of Interest Rate Changes On Specific Sectors?

    Authored By


    What Are Counterintuitive Effects of Interest Rate Changes On Specific Sectors?

    In the complex dance of finance, interest rate changes often lead to unexpected consequences across various sectors and asset classes. From tech stocks defying rising rate logic to the nuanced effects on equity sectors, we've gathered insights from a Real Estate Investor and a President. Here are the top four counterintuitive effects they've observed in response to your question.

    • Tech Stocks Defy Rising Rate Logic
    • Lower Rates Inflate Home Prices
    • REITs Thrive Amidst Interest Hikes
    • Interest Shifts Affect Equity Sectors

    Tech Stocks Defy Rising Rate Logic

    A counterintuitive example of how changing interest rates defy logical assumptions around impacts involves the relationship between rates and technology stocks:

    Conventional wisdom expects rising rates to negatively impact high-growth technology companies more reliant on leveraging debt or pursuing equity financing to fuel expansion, by increasing their capital access costs. Higher rates also diminish the relative valuations growth names command in markets compared to mature industries.

    However, historically, many tech stocks actually benefit from rising rate environments. This is partly due to financial markets anticipating strong inflation, which also indicates likely robust economic growth - which disproportionately advantages technology vendors selling productivity-enhancing tools. Higher enterprise and consumer demand offsets financing headwinds.

    Additionally, technology companies boasting substantial cash reserves and recurring revenue models not necessitating major near-term financing often absorb modest carry-cost bumps until prolonged periods of peak rates when gradual inflation does temper enterprise expenditure - making tech stocks a short-term hedge.

    So while adverse impacts eventually catch up across longer-term horizons if higher costs of capital choke off key projects, counterintuitively, technology stocks frequently see positive gain cycles through early-to-mid rising rate environments as enterprise customers accelerate digital adoption - defying textbook assumptions! Of course, exceptions persist across sub-sectors.

    Lyle Solomon
    Lyle SolomonPrincipal Attorney, Oak View Law Group

    Lower Rates Inflate Home Prices

    After all, when mortgage rates are lower, more home purchases can generally occur due to the increased purchasing power and affordability of buyers. However, the reality is that lower interest rates can actually have a counterintuitive effect on the housing market. Generally, when interest rates drop, homeowners will look to refinance their mortgages to take advantage of the lower rates. This can lead to a decrease in supply in the housing market as fewer homes are put up for sale.

    At the same time, the demand for homes may increase as more buyers are able to afford purchasing a home due to the lower interest rates. This increase in demand and decrease in supply can create competition among buyers, driving up home prices. In this scenario, even though interest rates are lower, the overall cost of purchasing a home may actually increase due to the higher prices. Lower interest rates can also lead to an influx of investors into the real estate market. With lower borrowing costs, investors may see real estate as a more attractive investment option and flood the market with their capital. This can also contribute to an increase in home prices, making it more difficult for potential homeowners to afford purchasing a home. Lower interest rates can also have a negative impact on the rental market. As mentioned before, lower mortgage rates may incentivize homeowners to refinance their mortgages and hold onto their properties instead of renting them out. This decrease in rental supply can lead to higher rental prices, making it more difficult for renters to afford housing.

    Brian Rudderow
    Brian RudderowReal Estate Investor, HBR Colorado

    REITs Thrive Amidst Interest Hikes

    On the contrary, regarding changes in interest rates, the case of the real estate investment trust (REIT) sector can be said to be counterintuitive. Conventional wisdom maintains that a rising interest rate environment is injurious to REITs, if not anything else, due to the more expensive cost of borrowing. However, in an improving economy—such that the demand for real estate pushes rents and property values upwards—interest rate hikes are often witnessed. This can translate to more income for REITs, which could serve as a cushion against some of the negatives emanating from higher costs. For example, well-positioned REITs in the commercial and residential sectors have shown resilience, even growth, during periods of moderate interest rate increases, as the rising demand boosts rental income. This introduces a bit of nuance into the answer, showing that it is vital for a person to understand the larger economic context within which interest rate changes occur when trying to judge their impact on different kinds of investment vehicles.

    Michael Carr
    Michael CarrPersonal Injury Attorney, Carr & Carr Attorneys

    Interest Shifts Affect Equity Sectors

    Interest rate changes often result in many counterintuitive effects; for example, their impact on equities.

    Equity is one of the asset classes most significantly influenced by interest rate changes. While interest rates don't directly alter stock prices, central bank decisions can affect investor sentiment. Higher interest rates increase borrowing costs, which can slow down business activities or increase expenditures. Additionally, when consumer spending drops, many companies may see a decrease in revenue.

    Stock markets might experience negative sentiment due to expectations of such downturns and slowdowns. However, certain sectors like banking, insurance, and brokerage might see improved performance due to anticipated higher revenues. As interest rates rise, investors often shift their funds from riskier assets like equities to more secure options like bonds or debt securities.

    Furthermore, sectors sensitive to interest rates, such as automotive and real estate, may be negatively impacted by increasing rates.

    Eric Croak, Cfp
    Eric Croak, CfpPresident, Croak Capital